Pittsford Farms Dairy in Pittsford

Pittsford Farms Dairy in Pittsford
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

44 N Main St, Pittsford, NY 14534-4494, Pittsford

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
Features
  • Takeout
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Seating
  • Parking Available
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Kids
  • Local cuisine
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

7:00 am

Wednesday

7:00 am

Friday

7:00 am

Sunday

7:00 am

do they have good icecream

Some of the best ice cream

Is your cream grass-fed by any chance? Thanks!

No, the milk they receive is in no way considered grass fed. Jonathan: The two farms that I know to have been supplying the milk are not grass fed. They are fed a silage/grain diet and they are very large farms. That is not considered grass fed. Jonathan--do you know the farm name? It is my understanding that Pittsford purchases milk through a large area Co-op and the cows are definitely owned by the farm, not by Pittsford Dairy.

Do they have any dairy free ice cream that is Not sorbet

Yes, they have normal dairy free ice cream in various flavors.

Can you buy pints of ice cream to go.

Yes you can but I believe they are limited flavors

Does Pittsford Farms deliver milk in the rochester area, milkman-style?

Not sure if they deliver but Wegmans sells their milk

Is the Icecream shop open

Yes, to-go only though

I live their milk and wanted to recommend it to others. However, 3 friends have had breast cancer. Is Pittsford Farms organic and grass fed?

If they are, they don't do anything to indicate such on their packaging, so I'd guess not.

Does the Pittsford ice cream contain corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, or cornstarch? I can't digest those ingredients. Unfortunately they are found in most ice cream.

Call them and ask

Do they sell dry ice?

No

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Pittsford Farms Dairy
KF
Kevin Fitzpatrick
google
04.24.2024
5/5

The best ice cream around, great friendly service!

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MS
Mokondis Smith
google
11.12.2018
4/5

Sometimes the bake goods leave something to be desired, they fall a little short. Ice cream products are great, milk products are great, what spoils it all, charging $.10 a bag. Did you give us credit for the plastic bags you no longer use, no! Are you donating this $.10 to a foodbank, probably not.One would think that for the prices you charge, a customer would not be asked to spend $.10 for a bag, particularly after spending $ 40.00. Does not leave a good taste in ones mouth.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
SL
Suzanna Law
google
11.06.2018
5/5

Beautiful farm shop, with a lovely cafe and bakery. This place makes me so happy and although I havent eaten here (always in a rush) everything smells delicious and all the food we have bought there have been awesome. Will be back.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
SW
Stephen Wallace
google
10.09.2018
4/5

Would have been 5 stars but the scoop portions in a cup were pretty small. But the taste and flavor selection was outstanding. And the staff are hard working and friendly. Proper COVID precautions were appreciated.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
KG
Kirill Gilbert
google
09.06.2018
5/5

My deadbeat wife has been bringing me to Rochester for over a decade, and she's been holding out on me. I don't know if it's grounds for divorce, but I can't believe this was my first visit to Pittsford Farms Dairy.Not only do they have tons of interesting and delicious flavors of ice cream, all sorts of cookies, elaborate and awesome ice cream cakes, the best pies I've found in Rochester (outside my mother-in-law's kitchen), excellent palmiers and scones, a nice array of local sauces and jams, and all the cheese...They also have these pepperoni, garlic, parmesan croissants, which are the flakiest, savoriest (that's a word), and absolute best snack to have when you're walking around and getting obscenely hungry picking out all the things.I've changed my mind. Keeping these croissants away from me for over a decade is absolutely grounds for divorce.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
SR
Sharilyn Ross
google
09.04.2018
5/5

Great ice cream! Also set up well for social distancing and flow. Easy to get in, order ice cream and exit. There's lots of outdoor space to enjoy your treats.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
TJ
Tristan Julian
google
08.27.2018
5/5

Anyone who goes to Pittsford absolutely needs to visit the Pittsford dairy. It is a very cute bakery and ice cream shop that has so much to offer. Staff is very friendly and I have never had a bad experience. There are multiple selections of ice cream, cookies, pies, baked goods and so much more. Plus, there is an abundance of seating outside allowing for lots of social distancing and a great place to enjoy your treat!

Pittsford Farms Dairy
AT
April Termine
google
08.12.2018
5/5

We love the dairy!! So great to see them busy today :-)

Pittsford Farms Dairy
DC
Dai Che
google
08.04.2018
5/5

Ice cream/yogurt is fantastic. Chocolate milk is to die for. Staff is friendly,polite and efficient. Customers are a$$ hats. Masks seemed like speed limits-a suggestion. 1 covidiot in a gray BMW M3 almost ran over some one in the parking lot. I picked up trash around the bench we sat at. No 2 meter social distancing while in line. Love it and cant wait to get some eclairs, but it might have to wait until after the second wave.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
CM
Carolina Margaria
google
08.01.2018
5/5

Both the ice cream (I had the vanilla custard in the waffle cone) and fresh baked bread were delicious. The place is charming, sells quality products, and was well worth the drive.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JK
Jon K
google
07.27.2018
5/5

Always good. Have never had a bad experience.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JR
Jacob Rumpf
google
07.19.2018
5/5

Always amazing. The line is long but moves fast.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JD
Joel Drake
google
07.16.2018
5/5

The best ice cream I have ever eaten. We got the cinnamon and a scoop of peanut butter fudge. The cinnamon was incredible! The creamiest ice cream you will taste. I would suggest getting one of the lighter flavors (cinnamon, vanilla, etc.) to best appreciate the creaminess of the ice cream.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JG
John Gariboldi
google
06.19.2018
3/5

We used to love this place. Sizes got smaller prices got bigger. Good ice cream though!

Pittsford Farms Dairy
OY
Oof You
google
06.09.2018
5/5

Very good, super friendly service and great prices for the quality.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JG
Jon Gray
google
05.23.2018
4/5

Friendly, with a good amount of variety in a very welcoming environment that supports the ethos of locally produced food and dairy. Plus you can still get the old-fashioned milk in glass bottles. A good place to get good-tasting butter milk as well as cheese curds. The selection of charcuterie isn't perfect, but still has some stand-out items. Definitely worth second, third, and fourth visits, etc.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MY
Michael Young
google
05.13.2018
5/5

Great ice cream. Multiple dairy free options which are quite good.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
ES
Ewelina S
google
05.11.2018
5/5

This place never dissapoints me! Love the extra outdoor benches and spaces during coronavirus! You gotta try their coconut almond crunch! It's to die for ❤️

Pittsford Farms Dairy
AH
A HJ
google
05.04.2018
5/5

The fig scones was amazing and the croissants flakey. Glass bottled milk selection is great, too.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MR
Marty Rogachefsky
google
05.01.2018
3/5

I was a bit disappointed by Pittsford Dairy. I got the Kaluha Mudslide. It was good, but not great. There were nuts in it, which I wouldn't have known based on the name of the flavor. I wish they had a description of the ice cream underneath the name. The double was pretty big, but cost $4.75.I appreciated that there was a lot of outdoor space. Great for sitting, eating ice cream and social distancing. The ice cream here is famous for being very creamy, but maybe I'm just into flavors that have a lot of mix-ins, because the Kaluha Mudslide just wasn't doing it for me.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
BR
Barb Rasp
google
04.19.2018
5/5

Delish,creamy ice cream🍦

Pittsford Farms Dairy
EC
Ezra Chona
google
04.04.2018
5/5

Super friendly place to shop with great selection of milk

Pittsford Farms Dairy
AP
Ann Publow, SPHR
google
03.23.2018
3/5

Love Pittsford Dairy, but there is absolutely no enforcement of social distancing inside. Not ok.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
SB
Swede Bede
google
03.10.2018
3/5

I love the ice cream there! Best one in the area! But the way they handle the customers is really messy. I can’t even have a chance to pick the flavor that I want since there are lots of people in front of me and there are no lines. They need to organize the place again. Other than that it’s an amazing place.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JD
Joseph Demeis
google
02.18.2018
5/5

Absolutely the best milk, ice cream and other dairy products in the area. Milk that still comes in glass bottles, and the best ice cream you ever had.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
CB
Cornelia Bullock
google
02.15.2018
5/5

Fresh Ice cream, sorbet's & coconut milk ice cream Yum! Plus Other Treats Lots of Baked Products

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MU
Mark Upshaw
google
08.17.2017
5/5

Great Ice cream!! They are able to take orders during COVID-19.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
PC
Pete Carmina
google
08.11.2017
5/5

Of you're looking to lose weight this place is not for you! If you like yummy pastries and coffees and pies then this place is definitely for you! The pastries were unique and flavorful and to die for. The coffees were phenomenal. The ice cream was awesome according to my 10 year old! The feel of the shop is very rustic and very relaxing and inviting.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MS
Maddy Stoll
google
08.08.2017
4/5

the facility is an overall good environment, and i love going there and the ice cream is bomb. BUT... there seems to be an old woman that lives in the house on the property that yells at people who sit on the piece of land in front of her house. i went to the dairy w my friends during pandemic, so there was no outdoor furniture. so, unknowingly me and my friends sat on a strip of land in the vicinity of her house. she resorted to yelling at us and throwing nuts at us. i feel that the situation could have been handled better on her part. this could be an issue in the future, considering that me and my friends are 14 and we were very rattled, and if there was a family w small children there, that could upset and scare the children. again, pittsford dairy is a wonderful facility, but there seems to be a communication issue over property lines.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
DH
Dr. Heather Feinman
google
07.22.2017
5/5

The ice cream is phenomenal. The service is wonderful and you can't beat the atmosphere.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
CM
Cody Maines
google
07.20.2017
5/5

Best ice-cream around, but usually busy if you want service.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
WM
Wyatt Mirek
google
07.01.2017
5/5

Very good custard and service, this is a great little place to find a snack!

Pittsford Farms Dairy
PG
Phil Garrod
google
05.04.2017
5/5

What an amazing place, 1st time there the ice cream was wonderful the selection was amazing must have been 50 different flavors, great inside store area, and very good Covid 19 spacing and cleanliness.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MN
Marte Noeren
google
04.27.2017
5/5

I'm in love with this place. Everything is made fresh, from the ice cream to the bread and the sweets. If you want some good ice cream with more than just the regular flavors, this is the place to go.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
LN
Lisa Narburgh
google
04.12.2017
5/5

Experience for first time was amazing. Loved it

Pittsford Farms Dairy
RY
Ravi Yelleswarapu
google
03.21.2017
5/5

Came here for ice cream and it was great. The neighborhood is really nice with a ncir trail to walk by. The ice cream is not that expensive and there are lots of flavors with many different other snacks. Would highly recommend. Many restaurants in the area also offer ice cream from here but might as well just get it at the source.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
Cm
Christopher morales
google
03.10.2017
5/5

Great atmosphere for some ice cream with the kids.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JB
Jeremy Brown
google
02.19.2017
5/5

The milk is amazing (people tell me that they can’t tell the difference between Pittsford dairy and grocery store milk but you can). It is a little pricey and the glass bottles are a $2 deposit but you get that back when you return them. Aside from the milk, the baked good, ice cream and coffee will have you coming back again and again. The only problem with the place (especially on a nice summer day) is parking, but you can always park on the main road and go for a little walk.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MW
Michelle W
google
02.12.2017
5/5

Coconut Macaroon ice cream is to die for. Cute store with lots of local ingredients and products.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MF
Mike Frederick
google
01.18.2017
5/5

What’s not already been said about Pittsford dairy their ice cream is second to none, from the flavors or the day that you can get in a cone, sundae or shake to the best soft serve I’ve ever had you can’t make a bad selection.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
PP
Pistol Pete Luciano
google
11.16.2016
5/5

Best icecream and dairy in the city Soo good. Very nice old time country atmosphere, inside also.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
KC
Kristen Coakley
google
08.01.2016
5/5

Amazing baked good, homemade ice creams and the BEST chocolate 🍫 milk 🥛 anywhere. They have an amazing and delicious assortment of ice cream flavors- if you like mix ins, be sure to try their cookie monster flavor!All this is available in a super cute store where you can even watch them package the milk. Also appreciate the use of glass for sustainability.A must try if you are in the Pittsford area.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
JA
Jonathan Ayala
google
07.21.2016
5/5

A little background, here. Phase 3 opens today in Rochester, NY, so I thought it would be nice to celebrate that with an Ice cream from here. I was surely not disappointed at all. 5 stars for Pittsford Farms Dairy, and an additional star for being the perfect place to celebrate Phase 3 in Rochester, NY.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
sr
sharon richnelli
google
06.17.2016
5/5

Everything was fresh & delicious. Plus- very clean, most people were socially distant and the staff was very helpful and friendly.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
macluvva
google
06.11.2016
5/5

Delicious ice cream and baked goods. Great atmosphere and decor. Just an awesome place to be and enjoy!

Pittsford Farms Dairy
TW
Tyler Warren
google
05.25.2016
5/5

So I am an avid Ice cream connoisseur and it's my favorite dessert. This place blows every ice cream ever made out of the water!! Amazing ice cream, super good milk products and baked goods as well.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
UFAME
google
03.18.2016
5/5

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had. They also have baked good cookies, muffins, cannolis, and bread.

Pittsford Farms Dairy
MW
Matt Will Grundman
google
01.22.2016
5/5

This place is amazing!!! Do not miss out! Cannot wait to go again. We loved it

Pittsford Farms Dairy
ES
Emily See
google
01.19.2016
5/5

Delicious ice cream, milk, and so much more. I love their vanilla ice cream

Pittsford Farms Dairy
AC
Anthony Casabianca
google
01.12.2016
5/5

While it is on the pricier side. The products are excellent. The soft serve custard is delicious, and their in house dairy is the best around.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 15855866610

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!